jaimeilo – Precarious Ecologies: Science and Social Justice in the Production of Environmental Knowledge

March 25, 2023March 25, 2023

Introduction for “Life After Concrete: Imagining the Future of the LA River”

by Lauren Kelly

Once, the Los Angeles River ran a wild course across the LA Basin. During California’s long dry seasons, the river would disappear from the surface into the porous ground, only to return in the form of dramatic floods and surges during wet winters. Indigenous peoples, such as the Kizh-Gabrieleño, coexisted with the LA River for thousands of years. Native groups established a village-state named Yaangna at the section of river that runs above ground year-round, known today as the Glendale Narrows. They used the river water to cultivate a forest of oak trees, along with pruning, weeding, prescribed burning, and other methods of vegetation management. These river ecologies were transformed by Spanish settlers, who violently displaced Indigenous communities. Mexico gained control of the LA River in 1821, but lost it when the US took over through a war of conquest in 1848.

Over the last century, the city of Los Angeles dramatically transformed the river itself. Developers pushed neighborhoods further into the river’s historic floodplain. The urban sprawl edged right up to the banks of the river. These precarious development plans exposed urban residents to the river’s periodic floods, killing people and damaging buildings. To ease these issues, city officials charged the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers with flood control; in turn, the Army Corps of Engineers encased the river in concrete. This long process was completed in 1970, and essentially transformed the once-wending river into a concrete storm drain, which – along with the network of concrete gutters throughout the city – whisked stormwater straight to the ocean. This system prevents flooding, but it also precludes rainwater capture to supplement the city’s water supply.

Despite the unsightly nature of the river’s concrete conduit, the LA River has become an iconic landmark in the minds of Angelenos over the last several decades. Indeed, it developed a cinematic mystique when several films used its channel as a backdrop, such as Point Blank (1967) and Grease (1978). The river has also grown to symbolize a multitude of different visions for LA’s future. In the 1980s, environmental movements started advocating for returning the LA River to a more natural state. Environmental justice groups protested the disproportionate burden of pollution and lack of green space shouldered by poor communities of color living near the LA River. Other Angelenos view the LA River’s clashing aesthetic of nature and concrete as an ideal place for creating art, and still others see it as a site for recreation. In 1996, LA County released its first Master Plan for revitalizing the river, a plan that stakeholders have continued to debate for the last two decades. LA passed an updated Master Plan in 2022, although many community groups withdrew their support when they learned that the plan does not adequately address social and ecological equity issues. Many Indigenous peoples in LA also argue that the county’s planning process has deprioritized their concerns about protecting cultural resources. The question of where to go from here remains unsolved, and we look forward to diving into these themes with our panelists.

Food Justice and Ecological Precarity in Los Angeles

Hanna Garth, Assistant Professor of Anthropology, Princeton University

Monday, February 27, 2023
2:00-3:30pm PST
Doheny Memorial Library (DML) 240
In-person event
RSVP here

This is the fourth event of the 2022-23 Mellon Sawyer Seminar Precarious Ecologies: Science and Social Justice in the Production of Environmental Knowledge.

This event is co-sponsored by the USC Center on Science, Technology, and Public Life and the USC Center for Latinx and Latin American Studies with support from the Mellon Foundation’s Sawyer Seminar Program.

October 5, 2022October 5, 2022

Opening necessary conversations at the Inaugural Forum of the Mellon Sawyer Precarious Ecologies Seminar

September 27, 2022

The inaugural forum of the Mellon Sawyer #PrecariousEcologies Seminar brought together several scholars, policy-makers and civil society activists. The forum served as a first chance to foster a conversation on the challenges, opportunities and new avenues of collaboration that arise between academia, government, and civil society in the context of the ongoing climate change crisis. While participants expressed a wide array of interests, priorities and approaches in relation contemporary environmental problems, the forum also revealed the many opportunities for collaboration that exist today both amongst different kinds of researchers and between academia, government officials and communities.

The forum was opened by a keynote presentation offered by Director Marta Segura, the founding Director of the Climate Emergency Mobilization Office (CEMO) for the City of Los Angeles. Director Segura provided details about her position as the founding Director of the CEMO, where she is working towards the creation of a network of equitable climate policies and strategies of climate emergency mitigation with the aim to align priorities and maximize resources in the city. Further, she reflected on the importance of universities in grounding truths and testing innovations with the common goal of achieving a more just and equitable future, and invited USC to expand investments and research in alliance with marginalized communities as a necessary contribution to solve the pressing issues raised by the climate emergency in the city.

Mrs. Segura’s keynote presentation was subsequently discussed by Professor Manuel Pastor, Distinguished Professor at USC’s Departments of Sociology and American Studies & Ethnicity. Drawing on his long experience conducting collaborative research with civil society organizations and community leaders, Professor Pastor offered ten lessons to foster just and productive dialogues between researchers, policy-makers, and communities. Such lessons emphasized the need for researchers to be self-reflective on their role as allies of the environmental justice movement by acknowledging the wisdom and intellectual prowess that arise from communities themselves.

Next, our inaugural event continued with a research forum where a panel of USC scholars reflected on the challenges of conducting research on social inequality, sustainability and environmental justice in southern California and beyond. While each panelist drew on their particular disciplinary traditions and methodologies to introduce their research to the audience, the conversation showed that the ongoing environmental crisis is increasingly demanding from researchers to foster interdisciplinary dialogues across disciplines and imagine new forms to delivering publications and research results to the public.

The panel included Andrea Ballestero, the Director of the Ethnography Studio and an Associate Professor of Anthropology; William Deverell, the Director of the USC-Huntington Institute on California and the West (ICW) and a Professor of History; Jill Johnston, the Director of Community Engagement in the Division of Environmental Health and an Associate Professor of Population and Public Health Science; John Wilson, the Director of the USC Spatial Sciences Institute and a Professor of Spatial Sciences and Sociology; and Joe Árvai, the Director of the Wrigley Institute for Environmental Studies and a Dana and David Dornsife Professor of Psychology and Biological Sciences.

We want to thank all participants for a productive, enlightening, and inspiring first event. We appreciate everyone who came, and we look forward to meeting even more of you at future events!